Ad
News

What It Takes To Beat The Speed Of An 8-core Mac Pro By 50%

Published on May 14, 2008

You may not have heard about this small manufacturer of VFX workstations, but there is a good chance that you saw a movie or a TV show with special effects done on one of these machines. Read more

Computer helper speeds neuroscience experiments

Published on August 22, 2006

A computer system that monitors the behaviour of simple creatures for neuroscience experiments could ultimately help scientists develop new drugs, researchers say. Read more

HP rolls out blade workstations

Published on November 30, 2006

HP has rolled out the industry's first blade workstation which stores the computer safely away in the datacenter closet. The ProLiant Blade Workstation Solution is stacked vertically in blade chassis cabinets and several dozen can be placed in a standard 19" wide server rack. Read more

Trend Micro To Offer Online Internet Security Service Based On Cloud Computing

Published on March 13, 2008

Trend Micro is developing online Internet security services based on cloud computing, which will be a core business of the company over the next 10 years, according to company chairman and founder Steve Chang at a March 12 press conference in Taipei celebrating the company's 20th anniversary. Read more

Latest Reviews & Articles

System Builder Marathon: Performance & Value

Published on November 28, 2008

We tightened the budget on this month’s enthusiast-level system while loosening our belt for the low-cost gamer box by a similar percentage. Today we gauge the effect of these changes on performance and value and compare to last month's machines. Read more

System Builder Marathon: $1,250 Enthusiast PC

Published on November 27, 2008

On this, the second day of our System Builder Marathon, Don turns down the price tag of his mid-range build looking for a sweet spot just above the $1,000 marker. Let's see what sort of hardware he found for it! Read more

System Builder Marathon: $625 Gaming PC

Published on November 26, 2008

This month's System Builder Marathon is all about your feedback to us. We've revamped our entry-level and mid-range PCs with new price points. Let's kick things off with what we think is the best value at a $625 price point! Read more

The State Of The Personal Computer

Published on November 25, 2008

Where were we in 2008 and where are we heading in 2009? In his State of the Personal Computer address, Alan Dang shares his insights as a user of three different platforms: Mac, Windows, and Linux. Read more

  Tom's Hardware Forums » Games General » Games General Discussions » CGI Gone Awry: The Worst Special Effects of the Computer-Generated Era
 

CGI Gone Awry: The Worst Special Effects of the Computer-Generated Era




Word :   Username :  
 
Bottom
Author
 Thread : CGI Gone Awry: The Worst Special Effects of the Computer-Generated Era
 
"These go to eleven."
Profile: Tom's Games Team
More Information

Special effects have come a long way in the last 20 years. And unfortunately, they\'ve also set us back. Computer-generated imagery (CGI) has been used in film for nearly two decades, but a string of poor films and cheesy effects has made CGI a four-letter word for many. Here\'s a list of the worst offenders.

Related Product

Register or log in to remove.

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Really funny article. Although at the bad cgi animals in movies part I expected to see the likes of The Exorcist: Beginning, the horrible horrible Hyenas in the movie along with the rest of the subpar special effects. I really wanted to like this movie... but only some of the scenes were believable.

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

You should stick to writing about computer hardware.

Profile: member
More Information

I read and liked your story. I saw all of the movies that were mentioned and i agree with you on the bad parts. I dont really own an expensive tv but I had always wondered if those movies looked better on high definition tv's.
the movie charlie and the chocolate factory has to show some hope and gain respect for cgi. it's really amazing and i can't spot hardly anything wrong in it.
Drew carey's green screen show (improv) was on comedy central for awhile.
The league of extraordinary gentlemen was good up until hyde had to fight the other (cgi) transformed guy after he drank too much of jekylls potion. the actor who played dr jekyll had to wear a suit and spend hours in makeup then fight a poor looking cgi character.
great reading the little known fact about Streisand's former hair stylist haha. I like going to the IMDB and reading about movie goofs and trivia.


*edited. i removed the part about the oompa loompa because it was just mean.

Profile: old hand
More Information

My favorite is still from "Along came a Spider." The movie overall is pretty decent (althought highly cliche') and has NO NEED for CGI, but they had to start it out with the corvette crash from hell?!?

Profile: member
More Information

Quote :

I read and liked your story. I saw all of the movies that were mentioned and i agree with you on the bad parts. I dont really own an expensive tv but I had always wondered if those movies looked better on high definition tv's.
the movie charlie and the chocolate factory has to show some hope and gain respect for cgi. it's really amazing and i can't spot hardly anything wrong in it.
Drew carey's green screen show (improv) was on comedy central for awhile.
The league of extraordinary gentlemen was good up until hyde had to fight the other (cgi) transformed guy after he drank too much of jekylls potion. the actor who played dr jekyll had to wear a suit and spend hours in makeup then fight a poor looking cgi character.
great reading the little known fact about Streisand's former hair stylist haha. I like going to the IMDB and reading about movie goofs and trivia.


*edited. i removed the part about the oompa loompa because it was just mean.



Well as for C&TCF, I remember interviews with Johnny Depp & The Director, and both were impressed with the actual stages because almost everything was real, But yea Ive seen the movie with my daughter and it does have very good special effects.

IMHO, I don't think you can generate ANYTHING with fur to look realistic.

I thought I was the only one that thought that Spiderman shouldn't have been SO SGI'd. There were a few scenes were it wasn't completely necessary.

Profile: Forum Resident
More Information

I'm a little surprised that Star Wars: Episode 3 didn't make the list. For the most part, the film's CGI's are excellent. However, the final scene between Obi Wan and Anakin, specifically when they're fighting in the lava, looked horrible. It was almost show stopping in my opinion.

Profile: stranger
More Information

Why isn't the new King Kong on anyone's list???!!!

They used too much motion blur when Ann was being whipped around for a full minute (and in other fast scenes) with such force that it would have killed her the first time she switched directions. With real film, the motion would look choppy. (Horrible use of filmwork too. 24fps can't track so much motion.) They even screwed up a blue-screen effect near the end, and you can see some of the color reflecting on the leading lady. I could probably name more, but being such a terrible movie, I try to forget as much of it as possible. Who could possibly believe a gorilla (even that size of one) could break a t-rex jaw by ripping it open. Even if he did accomplish that, why would the t-rex die?

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Quote :

I read and liked your story. I saw all of the movies that were mentioned and i agree with you on the bad parts. I dont really own an expensive tv but I had always wondered if those movies looked better on high definition tv's.
the movie charlie and the chocolate factory has to show some hope and gain respect for cgi. it's really amazing and i can't spot hardly anything wrong in it.
Drew carey's green screen show (improv) was on comedy central for awhile.
The league of extraordinary gentlemen was good up until hyde had to fight the other (cgi) transformed guy after he drank too much of jekylls potion. the actor who played dr jekyll had to wear a suit and spend hours in makeup then fight a poor looking cgi character.
great reading the little known fact about Streisand's former hair stylist haha. I like going to the IMDB and reading about movie goofs and trivia.


*edited. i removed the part about the oompa loompa because it was just mean.



Well as for C&TCF, I remember interviews with Johnny Depp & The Director, and both were impressed with the actual stages because almost everything was real, But yea Ive seen the movie with my daughter and it does have very good special effects.

IMHO, I don't think you can generate ANYTHING with fur to look realistic.

I thought I was the only one that thought that Spiderman shouldn't have been SO SGI'd. There were a few scenes were it wasn't completely necessary.

I disagree with you on the fur thing...Chronicles of Narnia: "the thing, another thing and the other thing" had a lot of CGI and, well, the lion looked a lot real.

PS - Garfield movies should have entered this article

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Quote :

I'm a little surprised that Star Wars: Episode 3 didn't make the list. For the most part, the film's CGI's are excellent. However, the final scene between Obi Wan and Anakin, specifically when they're fighting in the lava, looked horrible. It was almost show stopping in my opinion.



Well, you'd have to add Episode 1 and 2 too...they all have lame parts (not only on effects unfortunately).

Profile: enthusiast
More Information

Quote :

Why isn't the new King Kong on anyone's list???!!!

They used too much motion blur when Ann was being whipped around for a full minute (and in other fast scenes) with such force that it would have killed her the first time she switched directions. With real film, the motion would look choppy. (Horrible use of filmwork too. 24fps can't track so much motion.) They even screwed up a blue-screen effect near the end, and you can see some of the color reflecting on the leading lady. I could probably name more, but being such a terrible movie, I try to forget as much of it as possible. Who could possibly believe a gorilla (even that size of one) could break a t-rex jaw by ripping it open. Even if he did accomplish that, why would the t-rex die?



Because he mentioned he wouldn't include B-Movies on the article ;)

:lol: :lol: :lol:

Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

I agree that the 3 starwars prequels should have been on the list. The only reason I can think of that they weren't is because they would have filled up nearly every category. I mean they did have some awesome effects, but there were so many terrible ones as well, especially in ep1.

Profile: journeyman
More Information

I didn't mind the "puffy" Hulk at all. I do think the dogs were silly though.

A movie that stands out to me was "Lost in Space", that little whatever it was creature they added wasn't even coloured right for the scenes creating a horrible looking CGI character that made no sense at all. Now imho that was the WORST example of CGI I had seen in a long time.

Profile: stranger
More Information

The one CGI effect that actually almost made me cry in sadness was seeing what they did to Yoda ... I had fond memories of Yoda from Return of the Jedi and The Empire Strikes Back, and the marvelous job that made a puppet a belivable lively character. The old one couldn t fly and jump around everywhere, but the new one has no soul ...

Call me Ishmael.
Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information

Hmmmm I guess you have to put things in perspective. I have seen a lot of movies in my life with a lot of cheesy special effects. Now a days if things are not cutting edge and perfect and don't pass as the real deal they are written off as bad but (WHAT ABOUT THE STORY). I remember seeing the first star wars movie when it cam out in 76-77 not sure of the year but I was 11 and I thought that was the greatest movie ever. I felt that way about a lot of movies that I saw as a kid. Now when I look back at them you see the cheesy special effects but that did not matter because the story was good. Just like video games if they are good they are good graphics don't have to be the best. Now I watch a lot of these new disney and pixar animation movies with my daughter and a couple that I saw had great graphics but the stroy was not that good. "don't judge a book buy its cover"

Profile: nimble knuckle
More Information
n°570523
08-31-2006 at 01:34:22 AM
Hide